Consent/Closeness + Our Stories of Thanksgiving: The Wednesday 1-2-3


As many of us in the United States travel to see family in the next couple days (both chosen and related), I’ve found myself thinking about stories of upbringing.

Or more specifically: the stories we're told during childhood that teach us who we are, who others around us are, how we might relate to the Universe, and who ultimately belong in “our group” and who don’t. The stories that, in one way or another, tend to shape our initial posture toward the world.

A colleague of mine, Catherine Quiring, developed a tool for helping us understand our narratives and their origins – it's called the Consent/Closeness Matrix:

As you look at the matrix, you’ll notice two axes:

  • Low consent - high consent (along the X axis)
  • High warmth - high distance (along the Y axis)

These axes, when placed together, contextualize four different quadrants: paternalism, authoritarianism, radical acceptance, and radical autonomy. I like to think of these as different contexts or energies from which stories come out of.

Here are some examples:

Paternalistic Narratives (low consent, high warmth):

  • “I know what’s best for you – now, here are six ways (you didn’t ask for) that you can be better.”
  • “We know what’s best for them – they should do this, this, and this. We can show them how.”
  • Children’s Book Example: The Booklets’ baking boo-boo: A story about obeying by Ken Gire

Authoritarian Narratives (low consent, low warmth):

  • “Do this or I will question your goodness/worthiness.”
  • “Good people do this, like us. Bad people do that, like them.”
  • Children’s Book Example: Pig Will and Pig Won’t by Richard Scarry

Radical Acceptance Narratives (high consent, high warmth):

  • “Try it out – I’ll be right here if you need support.”
  • “We work together to make sure everyone can love who they love and be who they are.”
  • Children’s Book Example: Lynx: Trust Yourself by Callie Christensen and Kelly Oriard

Radical Autonomy Narratives (high consent, high distance):

  • “You do you!”
  • “We all have the ability and capacity to make choices for ourselves.”
  • Kid’s Book Example: Welcome to Consent by Yumi Stynes & Dr. Melissa Kang

Obviously there are a ton of complexities and nuances within this matrix, but here’s a basic practice for you this week:

Take some time and reflect on your upbringing. Think about your experience of how these quadrants shaped the stories and teachings you were offered.

For each of the guiding questions below, try reflecting on the stories and teachings offered to you by 1) your family and individual family members and 2) communities you were a part of and specific community members.

Then, imagine where those stories would be placed if you were to put them on the matrix.

From which quadrant did you receive your foundational stories about…

  • how to behave?
  • who to hangout with?
  • what justice looks like?
  • how to view your body?
  • the Divine/God/Universe?
  • your ability to make choices?
  • your role in social justice work?
  • how to remain in your in-group?
  • finances and financial responsibility?
  • your sexuality and sexuality in general?
  • gender identity and “what it means to be _____?”
  • what to do with anger, sadness, and other big emotions?

To watch Catherine do a deeper walkthrough of this tool, check out her video here.

Questions

  1. From which quadrant did your story of Thanksgiving primarily originate? Who was involved in the teaching of this story to you?
  2. How has your understanding of Thanksgiving changed over the course of your life? What might that change look like if shown on the matrix? How have you embodied this change during the Thanksgiving season?

Resources


⏪ If you missed last week's email:

I shared a teaching about the wheel of power/privilege.


Sending you good vibes,

Andrew

The Gentle Change Newsletter

Weekly frameworks and practices to help you take meaningful action in impactful and sustainable ways.

Read more from The Gentle Change Newsletter

Hey Reader, A quick request: as we come to the close of the year, I have a reader survey for you! It’ll only take a couple minutes and will help inform what The Wednesday 1-2-3 looks like going forward. 📝 Please complete this short 2024 Reader Survey (And in case it helps: there's a cute tardigrade gif at the end of the survey 😂) Last week I was talking with a friend about burnout – specifically “activist burnout.” He mentioned how folks who engage in activism often go full-speed ahead until...

Hey Reader, At the bottom of today’s email is a free 25-minute mini-workshop I recorded for you. It’s all about how we hold the charge of this moment – the heaviness, fear, unease, and discomfort of it all – in a gentle and intentional way. Just wanted to make sure you saw it 🙂 Alright – onward to today’s prompt: A couple weeks ago, I wrote that we are collectively living in the midst of a disillusioning moment. I defined this experience as: A moment when the illusion of “how the world works”...

Hey Reader, With Thanksgiving Day tomorrow for those of us in the United States, I thought it would be a good time to bring back the Consent/Closeness Matrix, which I first shared about a year ago. Designed by my colleague Catherine Quiring, the Consent/Closeness Matrix is a tool for helping us understand the stories we carry within us and their origins. (If you can't see the image above, you can view it here.) As you look at the matrix, you’ll notice two axes: Low consent - high consent...