How to Build a Practice When You "Don't Have the Discipline" (The Wednesday 1-2-3)


If you’ve ever tried to create a new habit just to watch it fall apart after a week, you may have had the thought “I just don’t have enough discipline.”

And, for many of us, this phrase can quickly turn into shame, guilt, other negative self-talk, and ultimately no sustained movement toward our goals and our dreams – the things that brought us to want to build the habit or practice in the first place.

This is a natural outcome of having a discipline-based approach to habit-building, one that is constantly reinforced by society through:

  • rigid diet and workout plans,
  • hyper-structured meditation methods,
  • strict and inflexible goal-setting protocols, and
  • a never-ending worship of perfection and productivity.

Discipline-based approaches overlook our unique body needs, lifestyles, preferences, real limitations, passions, histories, and literally everything else that makes us us. Over the long-run, they're one-size-fits-all non-solutions.

So, if you have a new habit or practice you want to give yourself to, but are worried about “sticking with it,” I recommend trying out what I call Core + Secondary. (This was a super helpful framework for several folks in our last inner work cohort.)

Here’s how it works:

Instead of committing ourselves inflexibly to a specific habit or practice, this is an invitation to center on the quality of aliveness or connection you desire to build capacity for.

For example, if I want to feel more present in my life, I could say “I’m going to meditate 10 minutes every morning.” But…what happens when the kiddos were awake all night and I just don’t have it in me? Instead of entering the discipline-shame spiral of doom, I could center on my longing for presence and find another practice that day to help me cultivate that quality.

My core practice is a habit that fits me most of the time; my secondary practice is something I can do with ease when life inevitably happens.

In this example, I could have a core practice of 10-minute morning meditation and a secondary, more flexible practice of 3-minute box-breathing.

More examples might look like:

  • Core = going to the gym; Secondary = workout at home
  • Core = morning walk; Secondary = lunch walk
  • Core = morning pages; Secondary = quick gratitude journaling

Not only does this short-circuit the discipline-based “I must check the box!” mindset, it helps us build a real toolkit of habits and practices that serve our longings and help us move in the direction we wish to move in.

If this connects, here’s how to try it for yourself:

  1. Reflect on your longings. What quality do you want to build capacity in?
  2. Identify a habit or practice that could help build this capacity.
  3. Identify a smaller, more flexible (perhaps mini-version) habit or practice that would also build this capacity.
  4. Think about your body needs, lifestyle, sense of identity, and so on: do these practices fit you? (And if not, make changes!)
  5. Try it out and be open to tinkering until you find what feels good.

Questions

  1. What is a quality in your life you want to build more capacity for? What would become possible if you did?
  2. How does this approach land with you? What messages within you about discipline or habit-building does it challenge?

Resources


⏪ If you missed last week's email:

I shared a practice from Jessica Denise Dickson on self-connection.


Hope all is well-enough with you,

Andrew

IG: @andrewglang

The Wednesday 1-2-3

Frameworks and practices to help you navigate the stories you’re carrying, embody practices that help you feel present, and begin to move into action. Delivered to your inbox every Wednesday morning before you even wake up.

Read more from The Wednesday 1-2-3

Hey Reader, Since I began sharing with you about The Gentle Change Collective, I’ve been receiving some really great questions. I’ve compiled a few of them here in case you've wondered similar things! 👉 And if you want a refresher on what this program is going to look like, here’s the last email I sent you. Q: I’ve felt so overwhelmed by what’s happening in our country and abroad. I can’t help feeling like I need to do SOMETHING in my own small way. How can I identify what is mine to do in...

Hey Reader, A quick request: as we come to the close of the year, I have a reader survey for you! It’ll only take a couple minutes and will help inform what The Wednesday 1-2-3 looks like going forward. 📝 Please complete this short 2024 Reader Survey (And in case it helps: there's a cute tardigrade gif at the end of the survey 😂) Last week I was talking with a friend about burnout – specifically “activist burnout.” He mentioned how folks who engage in activism often go full-speed ahead until...

Hey Reader, When was the last time you got stuck in a negative thought pattern or memory? For me, this happens most often when I’m out walking. I’ll meander through my neighborhood, intent on connecting with nature, but instead find myself lost in a memory or what feels like a tornado of unpleasant imaginings based on a past experience. These kinds of moments are referred to as intrusive or brooding ruminations. Image Credit: Sandstone Care Luckily, there are some pretty wonderful techniques...